data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a9309/a9309504c42d73a7f013de680cabc0dddc239028" alt="Image result for dog meat trade south korea"
Summary:
The Winter Olympics, which was held in Pyeongchang, South Korea, has shed light on the very controversial issue regarding South Korea's dog meat trade. Some South Koreans make the argument that those who are trying to implement regulations against eating dogs are placing the value of dog life above human life. These same people also view dog meat as a cultural food and claim that they know the difference between "dogs being raised for companionship" and those that are raised for the sole purpose of being food; however, many people take issue with the way the dogs are treated at the dog farms. They are forced to live in cramped areas with no room to walk or sometimes even stand, and they are not fed nearly enough. The Wall Street Journal article states that in South Korea, "some 20,000 dog farms raise the animals for human consumption" and that "last year, about two million dogs were raised and killed..." Many Olympians from the Winter Olympics, including Gus Kenworthy, have adopted dogs and have begun to speak out about the "inhumane" ways the dogs are treated at the dog farms in hopes of pressuring dog farm owners to close down.
Attitudes, however, are changing. The younger generations of Koreans are beginning to look down upon the trade and many only see the dogs as pets. The president of South Korea, too, has tried to change the attitude about the status of dogs and has adopted a black rescue dog. Many dog farmers are attempting to get out of the trade, and their dogs have been brought to western countries to be adopted. While we have to be sensitive to cultural differences, we can definitely demand that animals that are raised for human consumption be treated humanely. In a country like South Korea that is becoming richer, the population probably does not need to rely on a cheap source of meat like dog meat, and they can begin to get rid of the practice.
Discussion Questions:
1. Do you see the validity of some of the arguments supporting the practice of eating dog meat?
2. Do you think there is a difference between dog meat and other types of meat like beef or pork (pigs are considered to be very social and intelligent animals)? Should we be eating them?
3. Is there anything else that the Korean government can do other than completely getting rid of this practice?
Link: https://www.wsj.com/articles/olympics-puts-spotlight-on-korean-practice-eating-dog-meat-1519555641