Thursday, December 4, 2008

"Dont expect big changes in foreign policy"

I chose this article because it has some relevance to discussions in class about Obama's cabinet and appointee choices, specifically those of Hillary Clinton and Robert Gates. Courtesy of the New Republic, Editor John B. Judis wants to have a little quality time with AP Gov students.

Ok, we get it, it takes time to maneuver any kind of dramatic foreign policy changes. The fact that things need to stay somewhat consistent with our previous trends is somewhat of a given. And I do think that the fact Obama kept Gates reflects this fact. The decision to keep Gates on board doesn't necessarily mean that Obama is going to up and invade Iran. From a purely common sense point of view, the great benefit of keeping Gates on board is that now we dont have to waste a bunch of time moving in new leadership for the Iraq war. I'm sure a bunch of people, including myself, would rather see somebody in power who is familiar with the situation and the department behind it, and that has the wherewithal to get our troops out in a timely manner (whenever that happens to roll around). Does this mean that Obama is breaking his campaign promises? Well honestly I haven't paid close enough attention to the finer points of Obama's Iraq time table, but does this mean that Obama plans to stand around in Iraq for another two years while we look for somebody else to invade? I seriously doubt it.
Another interesting point that Judis brought up was that the merging of the Bush and Obama foreign policies wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing. Specific examples he brought up were diplomatic relations between North Korea and Iran, as well as expanding our relationship with Russia. It seems interesting however, that Obama is given the heat when in actuality Bush seems to be moving towards a more moderate foreign policy. It will be interesting to see the finalized copy of foreign affairs that Bush leaves for Obama, and while im sure there are some interesting points of continuity between the two leaders, there are still gaping holes of policy differences that Obama will make changes upon coming his inauguration to the White House. His cabinet in particular, minus Robert Gates, definitely has a different ideological makeup than shrub's second term in office, and it will be interesting to see just how much of the United States foreign policy remains constant and how much of it is changed.

5 comments:

Chris Chan said...

Well the President and the President elect can't move out to fast leaving any loose ends, because as we saw regarding Osama bin ladden those loose ends could cause major trouble for us in the future. With how unpopular the war is I hope the president won't fold too much to peer pressure.

Well that last statement is idealistic they are still politicians but I hope they are smart about it.

Anonymous said...

I think that maybe Obama wanted a smooth transition. I really can't predict what he's going to do. I guess we just have to wait and see. If he does want to make significant changes, he'll probably want to make them while his popularity is high.
We have to get out by Iraq in 2010 anyways. But how he handles Iran is bound to be interesting, especially with Hillary Clinton by his side.

Harkiran said...

When looking at a world view, any drastic changes in foreign policy should be weighed before execution. Certainly, Obama's foreign policy will be different than Bush's, but a transition phase is probably necessary. Change is an inevitable part of progess. It is the speed with which change is executed that we cannot know just yet. Obama might not change too much just at the beginning of his term (as shown by his decision to keep Robert Gates as Secretary of Defense)because he will be a new president. He will need to prove himself before he has enough power to change the United States drastically.

Albert A said...

Well,President Obama had to be somewhat consistent in what refers to previous foreign policy. It won;t be the same, and i believe that the new president will have an influence in what is to happen in foreign policy.

ooleg said...

obama should make his changes in the hunymoon of his campeign wile he is going to be at his most popular. i personally do not think that obamas foreign policy will be anything like bush's and i also am 100 percent sure that obama will just waight around in iraq for no reason. i honestly believe that he wants the troops home