Nine year veteran marine Gary Stein, with only four months remaining in his
tour, is facing serious consequences for his most recent political outbursts
via Facebook. Stein, a self described
conservative, “hell bent on defending the constitution and preserving America’s
greatness”, has had a history of criticism of Obama, with multiple Facebook
postings slandering the president; he has even gone so far as to photoshop
Obama’s face over a poster of “Jackass: The Movie”. The final straw came when Stein posted to a Facebook
group that he would refuse to follow Obama’s orders; only later did he clarify
his statement, explaining that he meant only unlawful orders.
Stein is being charged with violating a Pentagon policy
which limits the political activities of service members, including “contemptuous
words against senior officials”, and in this case, the Commander-In-Chief. Stein’s attorney is in turn arguing that service
members who present their political views may do so as long as they do not
claim endorsement by the military, and therefore, do not violate the Pentagon
policy.
The Marine Corps administrative board, following an
extensive hearing for the sergeant, has recommended that the 26 year old Stein
be given an “other than honorable discharge”; if the recommendation is
accepted, Stein will be demoted, discharged, and will lose all his benefits. I feel that Stein’s punishment is extreme, and that while his criticism of our president is both rude and flawed, he does have every right to make said statements. What do you think of Stein’s situation? Is he within his first amendment rights, or does the military have jurisdiction to exercise their policy in preventing political commentary from its service members?
