Monday, September 14, 2015

Professor Ethan A Schmidt Shot on Delta State Campus in Mississippi


An American history professor was shot on Monday, September 14th, while sitting in his office at Delta State University in Cleveland in Mississippi.  The man shot, Ethan A. Schmidt, was the assistant professor of American history who taught both undergraduate and graduate courses at Delta State.  The campus remained on lockdown for several hours.  Law enforcement officials suspect Shannon Lamb, a geography and social science professor, of shooting Ethan Schmidt.  "Shannon Lamb is also a suspect in the death of a woman in Gautier, Mississippi earlier on Monday", police officials told reporters at a news conference (The New York Times).  "Cleveland Police Chief Charles “Buster” Bingham told an afternoon news conference that authorities did not believe Lamb was still on the campus", which is close to the Arkansas-Mississippi state border (Reuters).  Investigators said they believe the suspect drove away from the campus after the shooting.  "He could be driving a black Dodge Avenger", authorities said, asking anyone with the information to call police (CNN).  “We’re working right now under the assumption that both events are related,” a spokesman for the Gautier police, Matthew Hoggatt, told The Sun Herald in Biloxi. “We hope that they are not. But at this point in time, information indicates that they probably are linked in some way, shape or form.”

A deputy coroner in Bolivar County, Murray Roark, said the coroner’s office had been notified of the shooting around 10:40 a.m. A twitter post was made around 12:30 p.m. telling faculty and students to “please stay inside and away from windows,” (Twitter).  Officials said the shooting took place near Jobe Hall, where many of the university’s professors have offices. More than 3,000 students are enrolled at the public university and while students and professors remained barricaded in the buildings, some took videos and photos of the campus.  At about 1 p.m., one Instagram user wrote, “2 professors and 20 students in classroom ... no word on evacuation yet” (The New York Times).


Classes were cancelled for the remainder of the day and will be cancelled tomorrow as well.  Delta State University posted on their website that "counselors from other public state institutions will be on campus tomorrow to conduct group sessions at 10 a.m. and 1 p.m., and individual sessions will be available beginning at 10 a.m" (Delta State University).  "I am deeply saddened by the awful news of Ethan's passing," Sean Cunningham, the department chairman, said in a statement. "He was an outstanding teacher, scholar and friend. Even more importantly, he was an incredible husband and father. Our thoughts and prayers go out to Ethan's family" (New York Daily News).


How has social media - like Twitter and Instagram - helped keep our communities safe? Would the framers look highly upon social networking or would they view technology as a threat to the development of dangerous factions or extremists?  Having just learned about the case U.S. v. Lopez, should the federal government have the final say regarding gun control or should the states be the ones to decide this right?  School shootings are still continuing all over the country.  What measures should we take at the federal and/or state level to keep our schools safer? 


All Sources: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/us/delta-state-shooting-mississippi.html?ref=us

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/09/14/us-usa-mississippi-shooting-idUSKCN0RE1SL20150914
http://www.cnn.com/2015/09/14/us/mississippi-delta-state/
http://www.sunherald.com/welcome_page/?shf=/2015/09/14/6414159_happening-now-officials-called.html
https://twitter.com/DeltaState/status/643460450437451776
http://www.deltastate.edu/news-and-events/2015/09/additional-updates-from-delta-state-university/
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/active-shooter-reported-delta-state-university-campus-article-1.2359780

Source of the image displayed in this post: The New York Times.

Saturday, September 12, 2015

Russia Sends Troops To Syria, Obama and State Department Respond

After Putin's meeting with Iran's Quds Force commander in late July, Russia has gradually sent around 1000 troops to Syria, and these troops are equipped the same way as the troops that Russia deployed into Crimea(Russian version or US Rangers). Putin has said that Russia wants to help Syria defeat the islamic state and the ISIS organization. Putin, I believe, has made some valid points, saying that ,you cannot defeat the the terrorists with air strikes only. He believes that the best way to defeat the Islamic State is through the Syrian military because they are the best equipped for the job and they are down on the ground. This I do not agree with.


President Obama spoke out on this saying that, "We are gonna be engaging Russia to let them know that you can't continue to double down on a strategy thats doomed to failure." (Double down effectively means risking more to get a bigger reward) The president is talking about the military support that Russia has been providing for Syria by sending them weapons, and now they take it a step further by sending in forces hoping that they can get some sort of reward out of this.


The State Department however states "I don't know if we can call it a buildup necessarily" John Kirby (State Department Spokesman). Kirby is talking about the 1000 Russian troops that were sent to Syria. I disagree with the view the State Department is taking on this. I feel like this is a bit similar to the way the US reacted to the Rwandan Genocide, where the US tells the public, in a sense, nothing is happening, that we should be worried about. They do this because they either don't want to get involved, or they don't necessarily know what to do about the issue. I think this act by Russia does signal a buildup, because Putin is no longer just sending weapons, he is sending Russian soldiers. I see this is a "no duhh" situation, meaning that I don't think we should be questioning weather this is a buildup of Russian military involvement in Syria or not, we should question what the US will do about it?


I find it that the government has deceived us people way to many times over the years about what is happening in the world, weather by withholding information, or by providing us with false or misleading information. The reason why they are able to continually to do so, is because there have been no consequences for previous politicians or presidents who, after the fact, have been discovered to have intentionally spun or deceive the public in one way or the other. I believe the public has the right to always know the truth and be informed on what the US in doing on issues at hand. This is something that is not specifically addressed in the constitution, but it is a big issue that has affected this country many times.


A few things to think about:


Do you think the US should be worried about Russia sending troops in Syria and being involved with Iran as well? Is the Syrian military the ideal source to defeat the islamic state?


Secondly, Why do you think the State Department is downplaying these events that are occurring? Do you disagree or agree with the State Department?


(Feel free to comment on these or any other topics)


Article: FoxNews


Shutdown Politics Divide GOP

“Perhaps the most unconcealed aspect of American politics is the obvious gall with which politicians secretly try to secure reelection” -Daniel Jun, speaker of quotes and claimer of random years since 2013.

An upcoming government shutdown is creating a divide between Republican senators. This shutdown, scheduled to happen at the end of September, has elicited both support and vehement rejection. This vehemence specifically stems from two Republican senators, Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin. The two claim that having a government shutdown would only hinder the Republican Party, but there are realistic queries as to their motive, namely reelection. And this cynical worry is actually bolstered with hard evidence.

The article states that “the GOP paid no political price in the 2014 election for shutting down the government in 2013… it is not irrational of [Cruz, a Republican in favor of the government shutdown] to think that shutting down the government will be a cost-free endeavor (from a GOP political perspective).”

However, there are several aspects of election that may make the government shutdown less than simple for the Republicans. In presidential election years more Democrats tend to be politically active, meaning that a 2016 government shutdown could have unexpected consequences. In addition, Johnson is a weak candidate in his state, so a shutdown may actually create negative results while not affecting those already in good standing with their constituents. This is also the second government shutdown in two years, and the cumulative effect that this could have is completely unknown. Finally, the Republicans are attempting to gain control “over the House, the Senate, and the White House, simultaneously, for the first time in a decade” and Democrats may be less than happy with this grab for power.


Is a government shutdown really a good idea? And, as a side note because this came up earlier in the article, should we have elected officials who can run for as long as they are reelected?

Link to the article here.

Friday, September 11, 2015

Lazy Narrative Journalism for the Quadrillionth Time

Journalists shouldn't get spun as often as they do. Working on a tight deadline is no excuse for reporting a generalization that isn't supported by basic analysis, yet it happens all the time. Jonathan Chait provides a topical example:


If you have heard about Jeb Bush’s new tax plan by reading political reporters, you have probably heard that it is a “proposal to reform the tax code” that will “crack down on hedge fund managers” (CNN), that it is “mainstream and ordinary” with “a populist note” (NPR), that it “challenged some long-held tenets of conservative tax policy” (the New York Times), and has “a nod to the populist anger roiling both parties” (The Wall Street Journal). It is, in other words, the same sort of coverage George W. Bush received when he unveiled his tax cuts in 1999, and which the campaign successfully cast as a populist departure from traditional Republican priorities.

On the other hand, if you have learned about the tax plan from some of the new policy-focused writers, you have drawn a very different impression. It is a “large tax cut for the wealthiest” (the Upshot) and a reprise of the Bush tax cuts, but “with more exclamation points" (Wonkblog). The difference lies between journalists who write narratives drawn from quotes from campaign sources and those who build their coverage on data. George W. Bush was fortunate that data-based journalism barely existed 16 years ago. His brother is counting on the power of narrative to obscure the data.

Thursday, September 10, 2015

Apple And Microsoft Have Disagreed To Hand Over Data To The Federal Government

Everyone has been talking about Apple's New flagship devices the iPad Pro and the iPhone 6s that were announced on September 9, 2015. However not many people know of the legal confrontation that is occurring between tech companies such as Apple and Microsoft, with the federal government. The government obtained a court order to the messages that were needed in a criminal case involving guns and drugs, but Apple responded that their iMessage system was encrypted and they could not comply.

Another case that has resurfaced in court is the case with Microsoft. This case goes back to December 2013, when Microsoft refused to comply to a warrant issued by the courts for emails in an investigation of drug trafficking.

The main argument being made by these two tech companies is that they have encrypted systems and thus they cannot give out that information. Part of the reason that they have encrypted their systems is because of the NSA info leak that happened a couple of years ago. They encrypted their systems because some of the information that leaked out seemed to point to the fact that the government had been hacking the private systems of these big tech companies and had access to their information.

The discussions and court arguments between lawyers have subdued for the time being, but a decision on this issue could be crucial to setting a standard on weather or not the federal government has the right to people's personal information that these tech companies have in their possession. Much like Marbury vs Madison where the judicial branch established itself the power to control whether laws are or aren't constitutional, the result of these two cases can decide weather the government has the right to access necessary information from tech companies when it is needed for a case. Personally, and I know a lot of people disagree with this, I would not have a problem if the government obtained access to peoples phone and computer records, but only when its believed that doing so can help prevent any attacks or catch criminals. I think a lot of people have a problem with this because they do not have trust that the federal government would act responsibly with this information, and some people just feel that they need to have some sort of personal privacy, otherwise what's the point of having freedom if the federal government has the ability to watch your every move. I can see this point of view, but I believe that security should always be a priority because protecting the lives of people is always a priority.

Something to think about:

Should the federal government have access to peoples phone and computer data when it will help in preventing an attack or catching a criminal? If so, who decides when its necessary to have this access and when its unnecessary?

Articles: Cnet, NYTimes


Where the states stand on Medicaid Expansion

Many states are still ambiguous towards the expansion of Medicaid.  Twenty-nine states along with the District of Columbia have already expanded Medicaid, the most recent state having agreed to do so being Alaska. However, it is important to note that Alaska lawmakers attempted to stop Governor Bill Walker from expanding the Affordable Care Act’s program, otherwise known as ObamaCare.

Interestingly, four states are looking into expanding Medicaid. They are Montana, Tennessee, Utah, and Wyoming. Montana released an alternative Medicaid expansion plan for a routine public comment period, but it is not likely to be passed. The governor of Tennessee, a Republican, is publicly against ObamaCare, but does intend to use federal funds to provide coverage for an additional 200,000 low-income residents by helping to purchase health plans. This plan was scrapped in February 2015 by a key Senate committee. Utah is still struggling to create a viable plan that could pass in the Legislature, and Wyoming shot down its own expansion plan in February 2015 as well.

Nineteen states have not expanded Medicaid. It is clear that political factions have a role to play in this as many Republican governors have refused expansion. Louisiana Governor Bobby Lindal (Republican) stated that expansion “would cost his state $1 billion over the first 10 years.”

This entire blog post is meant to incite one meaningful question: what are the states’ responsibilities in providing their citizens with healthcare? Are states meant to keep a watchful eye over their citizens, keep the wolves away from the herd, but simply observe passively as the sheep to die from accidental injury and disease? Many countries all over the globe, from Austria to Russia, Hong Kong to New Zealand, provide universal health coverage.  


It is also necessary to note that the article that this blog post is sourced from is clearly inflected with Liberal views. The article provides, ultimately, Liberal propaganda (one example being that the article tended to provide statistics on the amount of people that Medicaid expansion could help, with just enough evidence favoring the Republicans to create a slightly neutral news article). Yes Medicaid will provide subsidies for many Americans who cannot afford expensive healthcare, but do such positive benefits balance out the problems Medicaid expansion could create?


Link to the article here

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Trump Continues To Climb Further Up The GOP Candidate Polls After Signing The Loyalty Pledge

On September 3rd, 2015 Donald Trump signed the Republican party's loyalty pledge stating that he would not be running on his own if he did not win the GOP's candidate race, and also, that he would back up whoever did win the race for the Republican Party candidate.(CNN) He was the only Republican candidate that had not signed the loyalty pledge and so, had received quite a bit of criticism of being considered "fake" because of his affiliation with the democrats and Clintons a few years back. Even though the pledge does not bind the candidates in any legal perspective, after signing it, Donald Trump rose even higher in the GOP polls where he now stands at 32.1% of votes, 18.3% ahead of his closest competitor Ben Carson who sits in second with 13.5%. (HuffingtonPost)

This pledge can be seen in different perspective through different people. Some Republicans might view this as a good thing because if Trump looses, he cannot run on his own and pull away the voters that would otherwise have voted for the Republican nominee. But on the contrast Trump along with the other GOP candidates have signed the pledge to back up whoever wins the GOP candidacy, meaning, if Ben Carson or Marco Rubio somehow manages to pull the win, the Democrats would be able to bash whichever candidates wins for being affiliated with Donald Trump in terms of the pledge. (Slate)

And why might is seem bad to be affiliated with Donald Trump for some people, you may ask?

Well, In addition to a lot of people thinking of Donald Trump as a racist old white man, there are mainly two arguments Donald Trump has made that I along with quite a few other Americans, find to be so ridiculous that they are actually funny.

First Donald Trump has argued that if he were president he would build a wall across the almost 2000 mile border between US and Mexico. In addition he would deport the 11.3 million illegal immigrants that work in the US at the moment. The reason I find this improbable to be consider and passed is because it would require a tremendous amount of money, time, and most likely military power to carry through. In addition the economy would be hurt, and this is without even mentioning the families that would be torn apart from deporting these immigrants.

Second argument Trump has made which seems ridiculous to me, but a few other GOP candidates agreeing to it in some way, is that if he won the presidency he would push for an of amendment to ban the birthright citizenship section of the fourteenth amendment. This section of the fourteenth amendment gives automatic citizenship to all babies born in US territory regardless if their parents are here legally or not. I myself do not agree with this because, being an immigrant(from Europe) myself, I find it that most immigrants, weather legal or illegal, come here so their kids can have a brighter future. Now in no way am I saying illegal immigration is a good thing and should be rewarded. I still think something has to be done about illegal immigrants coming to the US, but I do think that most people that come here to give birth to their children, do this so their kids can have a brighter future, and if any of us were put in the same situation we would do the same thing. In addition, the fourteenth amendments was put into action, in part, to protect the rights of the immigrants that were coming to the US in the mid to late 1800's. Amending it nowadays would be a bit ironic because you're taking away this right from the immigrants nowadays, that was deemed constitutional to the immigrants in the 1800s.

A few things to think about:

Would building a wall be reasonable for the US to do especially since 40% of immigrants come to the US by plane? Should we invest that much money to build a wall and deport almost 12 million immigrants?

Secondly, should we add an amendment to the constitution that amends part of the fourteenth amendments? Should the rights that immigrants have change over the decades?

Finally, How difficult would it be to try and get the bill passed for a 28th amendment amending part of the 14th amendment? Could it ever happen?

(Be free to comment a response to any of these topics or others you found interesting.)



Obama Orders Federal Contractors to Provide Workers Paid Sick Leave

Tensions between political parties seem to be on the rise again, and not in a good way. President Obama signed an executive order “on Monday requiring federal contractors to provide up to seven days of paid sick leave a year.” Obama then proceeded to publicly oust the Republican congressional leaders for endangering the economy. The current President of the United States continued from there to accuse Republican presidential candidates of undercutting American workers. Obama renounced the Republican candidates’ portrayals of themselves as “champions of the middle class” when they opposed labor unions.

It is important to note, no matter how obvious this fact may seem, that this was designed to his union base. However, this executive order will not go into effect until after his presidency as it must first pass a public comment period. This act, if passed as is, will hopefully bring about changes in state and local governments, expanding their leave policies.

Obama’s aggressive responses to the Republican candidates were implicit replies to Mr. Walker, who claimed “his battles with labor unions would prepare him to take on terrorists” and Mr. Christie who “said a teachers’ union deserved a punch in the face.”

Mr. Walker, however, retorted with by saying “I think the president and his allies fear us more than anybody else in this race because they know we don’t just talk about it; we get it done. We fight, we win, we actually get results.”

Prior to the current executive order, Obama sided against the Democrats in favor of new free trade agreements with Asia and Europe, inciting extreme anger within many Democratic political leaders.

Ultimately, how many of these decisions are actually for the people? There are clearly ample motives and secret vendettas possible in every action committed by Obama. Did he create this executive order just to get his party to like him again? Did he create it to use as a weapon against Republican candidates? Or did he truly believe in following through on justice and trying to help the people he swore to protect?

Link to the article here

France and Britain announce plans to accept more refugees in migrant crisis

French President François Hollande gives the announcement
 during a press conference on Monday.

On Monday, President Hollande announced that his country, France, will accept 24,000 refugees over two years and British Prime Minister David Cameron announced that the UK will accept 20,000 Syrian refugees over five years. An estimated 381,000 migrants have arrived in Europe in 2015, and about half are from Syria.
Cameron’s plan would likely accept only Syrians from refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan and Turkey, to discourage migrants from risking their lives in the perilous journey into Europe and to avoid favoring the refugees who could afford to pay for the trip into Europe at the cost of those who can not.
There are an estimated 4 million Syrian refugees living in Jordan, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Egypt and Turkey. (about 1.9 million in Turkey, 1.1 million in Lebanon, 630,000 in Jordan, 250,000 in Iraq, and 130,000 in Egypt, according to the UNHCR.)
Although they constitute the largest group of migrants, not all of the migrants are Syrians. Tens of thousands of Afghans, Etrians, and Nigerians, have come to Europe in 2015. People from these countries would not be included in Cameron’s plan, but might be able to find refuge in France under Hollande’s plan.
Cameron plans to expand the Vulnerable Persons Relocation Scheme, which would allow the accepted refugees to reside, work, and access public funds in Britain for five years, after which the refugees could apply to settle in the UK.
The 24,000 migrants President François Hollande would let into France would constitute France's part in a plan Hollande is pushing in which each of the 28 EU countries would take a share of 120,000 European migrants over the course of two years. Hollande has also called for “hot spots” to be established along the borders of Greece, Italy and Hungary, countries through which large numbers of migrants are passing. These “hot spots” would process asylum applications there and deny ineligible migrants before they make their way through Europe to countries such as France and Germany.   Both announcements came after a picture of a 3- year- old dead Syrian boy made headlines around the world, increasing international sympathy for the plight of migrants. Named Aylan Kurdi, the boy drowned off of the coast of Turkey after the boat he was on to get to Greece capsized. He was part of a Kurdish family fleeing violence in Syria. The image lead to calls in Europe to let in more refugees, and more pressure on political leaders to allow more refugees in.
Questions: What obligations do nations have in this crisis-- do they still have obligations to help refugees Saudi Arabia and other gulf states (like Qatar and Kuwait) have taken 0 Syrian refugees. Since Gulf states like Saudi Arabia helped fund fighting against Assad in Syria, are they obligated to take in Syrian refugees? Or do nations have no obligations to people of another country, regardless of their circumstances? Are European countries obligated to take in the refugees flooding into the continent? Is a state in which power is ostensibly derived from the people (referring to European parliamentary republics, not Saudi Arabia) obliged only to act in the best interest of its people, or do states have an obligation to help those in the greater global community with dire needs? When those two interests conflict, which should supersede the other?
The US has accepted about 1,500 Syrian refugees thus far and offers to accept 5,000 to 8,000 refugees next year. Should the US let in? Is the US obligated to promote the "general welfare" of humanity as well as her citizens, or does she only have to consider the well- being of her citizens?
All Sources: (in order in which they appear)
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/08/world/europe/europe-migrant-crisis.html?
hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&module=first-column-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news
http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/09/08/438539779/the-migrant-crisis-by-the-numbers
http://data.unhcr.org/syrianrefugees/regional.php
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-24583286 
http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-34171148
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/europe/France-to-take-24000-migrants-under-EU-refugee-plan-Hollande/articleshow/48856028.cms  
http://www.wsj.com/articles/image-of-syrian-boy-washed-up-on-beach-hits-hard-1441282847 (The picture of the Syrian boy can be found in this article. Warning: It is disturbing.)
http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/08/25/434576046/u-s-to-accept-up-to-8-000-syrian-refugees-next-year
Source of the image displayed in this post: Reuters.

Tuesday, September 8, 2015

State vs Federal, Budget vs Justice

California legislature is currently debating a reform of the state’s civil asset forfeiture laws which, if signed into law, would mean “law enforcement would only be allowed to seize property and money if a property owner is convicted of a crime. The legislation also prohibits law enforcement agencies from transferring seized property and cash to the federal government.” This last sentence makes it very clear as to why the federal government would be so against such a reform;it would lose assets should this be passed. The federal government threatens California lawmakers with the fear of losing eligibility in the federal government’s Equitable Sharing Program, from which “California law enforcement agencies received more than $89.6 million.”

There are dissenters to this legislation even within California. Alice Dery, deputy chief of the Justice Department’s Asset Forfeiture and Money Laundering Section, has made it clear that should the proposed legislation be passed, California law enforcement of all levels would not be eligible for the Equitable Sharing Program. Sean Hoffman, director of legislation for the California District Attorneys Association, wrote that the reforms “will cripple the ability of law enforcement to forfeit assets from drug dealers when arrest and incarceration is an incomplete strategy for combating drug trafficking.”

If, as multiple reputable sources indicate, the new legislation will only result in a lower budget and worse ability to combat drug traffickers, then the answer is clear: do not pass the legislation. However, it has already passed, with a vote of 38-1, and the state Assembly is to debate the changes this week.

Let us not forget, however, that this legislation would help to prevent the unjust acquisition of private property. But does this legislation that would inspire inefficiency in an already bureaucratically-burdened system provide better for the common good than the current system? What the article ultimately presents is a choice: lose millions of dollars of federal funding and help to stop the unjust theft of private property, or keep millions of dollars and be able to more efficiently fight crimes?

Link to the website here

Monday, September 7, 2015

Pope Francis' visit brings up Religion in US politics.

Pope Francis will make his first ever visit to the United States on September 22, 2015. In his visit, the Pope will first meet with President Obama at the white house. After doing so, he will give an address to a joint meeting of the United States Congress. This specific address is special, as it is something that has not been done by any other Pope in history. Pope Francis will then go on to New York city, and later give another address in front of the United Nations. Click here for more information.

The Pope's visit brings up the topic of religion in United States politics. The visit and the address that he will give to congress offers us a look at the great evolution of the acceptance of different religious views in US politics. Looking at Catholic religion we can see this distinct evolution by looking at how, "President John F. Kennedy had to defend his Catholic faith more than half a century ago," (CRUX) But nowadays this is not the case for politicians such as John Boehner (speaker of the House of Representatives) and Vice President Joe Biden, both of which are catholic and are so openly. These two politicians  in addition to many other catholics in US politics, do not have to "prove" themselves worthy for serving America just because they are Catholic, like President Kennedy needed to. This exemplifies the evolution of religious acceptance in politics that the United States has experienced throughout the decades. Even though Article 6 of the Constitution and the first amendment gave people freedom of religion when running for federal office, in the 19th and early 20th Century it was very difficult for a catholic to be elected to hold a high office in the US. This has now changed as nearly 30% of congress are Catholics(National Catholic Register). The Pope's visit, and especially the address he will give to congress has had people talking about the evolution involving religion in US politics and holding political office which I believe has been a great step forward because politicians should make their decisions on what the people they represent want and whats good for the country, and their personal religion should not affect the decisions they make in office.

In contrary to the federal government we see something different when looking at individual states. Article 6 of the constitution states that the government cannot issue religion tests to people running for office, but it didn't say that states could not do so. In fact there were states that had implemented some sort of a religion test in their constitution that tested weather candidates running for state office believe in God or a higher power. These tests were deemed unconstitutional and have been taken out for the past few decades but there are still a few states that have "language in their constitutions either requiring state officeholders to have particular religious beliefs or specifically protected"(Wiki) Wille I myself do believe in God, I still believe is is unconstitutional to have religious tests and even have language in the constitution like the states above do requiring religious beliefs in candidates, because it is discouraging people from trying to run for state office. The religious tests were deemed unconstitutional and I believe that was on the right grounds, but I also believe states should not have any sort of language concerning religion in their constitutions because there should be no correlation between political decisions and one's religion

Religion and politics is a very intricate thing to talk about, but is it even something we should even be concerned about? Because shouldn't politicians make political decisions based on what the people want, not their own religious beliefs? 

Secondly, should the federal government further interfere with the states mentioning of religion in their constitution when it comes to who can hold federal office? Was it enough to make all religious tests unconstitutional or should there be completely no mentioning of religion in a state's constitution when it comes to who can hold state office?


(Picture Link: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/06/us/pope-francis-is-coming-to-america-after-avoiding-it-for-78-years.html)

Trucker Wins Democratic Primary for Mississippi Governor

Robert Gray, the Democratic Nominee for Governor of Mississippi
 
JACKSON-- Robert Gray, a trucker from the small Mississippi town of Terry and an unknown, won the Democratic primary in the Mississippi race for governor, despite the fact that he never campaigned. In fact, his own mother never knew that he was running. 
Robert Gray owes his victory to two main factors-- (i) that his name was first on the ballot and (ii) that Mississippi voters do not to register by party, meaning that Republicans could vote in the Democratic primaries if they do not want to vote in their own party’s primary.
Gray won roughly 51% of the vote, beating two candidates who actually ran campaigns: Vicki Slater, a trial lawyer, and Dr. Valerie Short, an obstetrician-gynecologist.
This is by no means an isolated incident for Southern Democrats-- as the Democratic party has lost all of the hold that it once had over the South, statewide elections are almost certain to go to Republicans candidates, and serious candidates are often beaten by the first name on the ballot. For instance, in Tennessee, a man named “Charlie Brown” won the 2014 Democratic primary for governor, thanks in large part to the fact that his name was first on the ballot. Brown, a retiree, sent letter to state newspapers in which he commented that he would like to strap the Tennessee governor to an electric chair, due to Brown’s anger over the governor’s death sentence policies.
Gray’s win is evidence of the dismal state of Democrats in the South, and their growing irrelevance in Southern statewide elections-- in the Deep South, the Republican primary could be considered is the only vote that counts in gubernatorial elections, ie. the de- facto general election.**


Questions:
Uncompetitive elections and partisanship: Are uncompetitive general elections a threat to democracy, or merely a sign of deeply held beliefs? Is such partisanship an example of the threat of faction, as Madison mentioned in Federalist paper #10? Or rather, is it not a threat because their party allegiance comes from beliefs about what is best for the nation, and is not a case of putting the good of the party over the good of the people?
Do frivolous elections alway spell bad news for our democracy?


States’ voting procedures: Additionally, should all states have voters register by party? Would the election results have been different if only registered Democrats could vote in the Democratic primary?


**(Note that this only refers to the Deep South. Some States in the upper South, such as Kentucky, Missouri, and Virginia, have Democratic governors.)


Sources:
New York Times Article
Article from "The Tennessean," a Tennessee local newspaper
Image source: Andrea Morales for the New York Times, from the same article cited above.

An Aging Supreme Court


The Supreme Court of the United States, the most powerful federal court in all of the US, is composed of nine members with lifelong tenure. For some background information, their current ages range from 55 to 82, with the average age of the justices being 75 at the end of the next president’s first term.  Some, like the advocate group Fix the Court, believe this aging Court needs multiple reforms.

Fix the Court specifically believes firmly in a new system where Supreme Court Justices serve 18-year terms. Even Alexander Hamilton noted in Federalist 79 the dangers of a “superannuated [out-dated] bench.”  Fix the Court specifically cites the high percentage of 5-4 rulings under Chief Justice Roberts as a reason for change.

But close-cut decisions do not necessarily indicate a “partisan” bench. Just “this past spring… Chief Justice Roberts [a conservative] voted with the four liberal justices to save Obamacare” and that Justice Thomas voted against the Conservatives, “permitting Texas to refuse to print Confederate flags on license plates” (S.M.).

It is also necessary to mention that an infusion of new members will, at the very least, provide new views and beliefs in the Supreme Court. But is this beneficial? Do fresher voices provide more impartiality, more justice? What even is justice? Is it Christian values? Is justice pro-life or pro-choice? If justice has a dynamic definition, does it not make sense to have a similarly dynamic Supreme Court?

And, perhaps most importantly, are we high school students even capable of responding to these questions fairly?

Link to the article here.

Thursday, September 3, 2015

Kentucky county clerk defies court




Kim Davis made national headlines today when she was jailed for contempt of court for refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses. She defends her actions by citing her first amendment right to religious freedom.

Some have publicly applauded Davis, including Republican presidential candidates Rand Paul and Mike Huckabee. Says Huckabee, “The Supreme Court is not the Supreme branch and it’s certainly not the Supreme Being.” 

But Fiorina, another Republican presidential candidate, thinks differently. “First, I think that we must protect religious liberties with great passion and be willing to expend a lot of political capital to do so now because it’s clear religious liberty is under assault in many, many ways. Having said that, when you are a government employee, I think you take on a different role. When you are a government employee as opposed to say, an employee of another kind of organization, then in essence, you are agreeing to act as an arm of the government. And, while I disagree with this court’s decision, their actions are clear.”


It may not help that this is an issue that a lot of us feel very strongly about, but what do you think? Was it right for Davis to be charged with contempt of court? Is her behavior in any way defensible? How far do your first amendment rights go? Do you think others will be influenced or encouraged by Davis's behavior?

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

Passing the Iran deal

Obama’s Iran deal is getting ready to come to a vote in Congress. While many representatives have openly voiced criticism – actually, a majority of them – the bill is expected to pass. 

Congress usually votes to approve a bill. If both houses approve, the bill is taken to the White House where the president either vetoes or signs it. However, in this case, Congress is voting to DISAPPROVE the Iran deal. If this goes through, it will still make its way to the White House, where the President would, supposedly, veto Congress’s disapproval, and it would go back to Congress to see if there would be enough votes to override the veto. This means that as long as 34 senators approve the deal (and they do, as of today), the President’s deal will stick.

Sen. Mikulski of Maryland was the decisive 34th backer. She has served for three decades in the Senate already and will be retiring next year, which is probably relevant because it means she didn’t need to fear backlash from constituents that couldn’t vote for her next term anyway. 

What do you think of this loophole? Clearly, an argument can be made that this is bad because it is effectively minority rule – especially considering how hard it was to get these 34 together. 
Relevant NPR interview question: a reporter asked Obama, “Are you entirely comfortable going forward with a historic deal knowing that most of the people's representatives are against it?” and he responded saying, “Well, what I know is, is that, unfortunately, a large portion of the Republican Party, if not a near unanimous portion of Republican representatives, are going to be opposed to anything that I do, and I have not oftentimes based that on a judgment on the merits, but have based that on their politics…and I am confident that, as we see implementation, we will see, in fact, more and more folks pull out of the immediate politics of it and judge it on the basis of whether it was the right thing to do for the country.” (Read the entire interview transcript at http://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2015/08/10/431244020/full-video-and-transcript-nprs-interview-with-president-obama) 


Is it a politician’s job to represent our views or act in what he/she thinks is in our best interest? How much of how we elect our representatives is on the basis of how we trust them, their rationality and decision-making ability, and how much of it is dependent on how well we like the specific policies they advocate for? Does it count as democracy if they think they are representing the interests of their constituents even if those interests have never officially been voiced? Are situations like the passing of the Iran deal sometimes necessary so things can actually get done, or are they never justified? 

California Puts limitations on Solitary Confinement


Today I heard about the changes to the solitary confinement policy in California. After a lawsuit was settled, California says it is illegal to place prisoners in solitary confinement indefinitely. Some you ask where do the high risk, violent, totally evil prisoners go? The answer is to move prisoners to a new unit where they have more privileges, such as phone, and some leisure time.

This policy change comes after various court cases, hunger strikes, and studies reporting on how solitary confinement takes a toll on individuals more than it seems. The act of cutting off almost all interaction will affect their sanity. Along with the loss of sanity, some argue that solitary confinement does not really rehabilitate individuals. They also use the eighth amendment, no cruel and unusual punishment, to try to argue their point,m although I think I think that using the eight amendment is stretching it. There are negative affects to solitary confinement but the base of the act is to isolate someone, not torture them. However I do see pushing gang members automatically into solitary confinement, when they arrive, is unfair. Individuals should not just be judge on their past. Prison is meant to rehabilitate individuals, judging them on their past is against that.

The other side believes that prisoners are prisoners; they have no freedoms or guaranteed rights as they have lost that privilege due to breaking the law. Some guards also warn that solitary confinement is a method of suppressing the prisoners. Conclusively I think that solitary confinement should not be done away with, but like what this policy changes is prevent individuals to be in solitary confinement from being indefinite and more than 10 years. No matter the act there should always be some change in actions or violence.



You can read the original article on The New York Times here

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

Pope Francis Authorizes Priests to Forgive Women of Abortions

Pope Francis

The Catholic Church has always condemned abortions, therefore excommunicating any individual who has undergone or taken part in giving an abortion. Although there are various exceptions, such as when the mother's life is in danger, when the loss of a baby is unintentional, or rape victims. However, these are still very point of view based and views are very different based on the location or social view on abortions.

But on September 1st Pope Francis has decided is too allow priests to forgive women who underwent abortions during the Church's Jubilee year of mercy from December 8th till November 20th in 2016.* Although I am personally pro-choice I still understand and respect why some religions feel to protect even fetuses or babies from abortions.Though I think it is barbaric, especially, to not allow abortions after rape.

Ultimately this news just furthers how accepting Catholicism is becoming. Rather than being an exclusive religion where only the hardcore individuals are allowed, it is evolving with the different social norms. I believe that everyone should be able to follow whatever religion in whatever method they feel as religion is more ambiguous than set in stone laws that every follower must follow. The way another person follows a religion does not affect another's and I do not see why Catholicism is so restricting when every human is different.

Read the article on CNN here
*Note: Jubilees are certain years when "indulgences" are forgiven, this jubilee has a focus Mercy and forgiveness.

The problem with Google's driverless cars








stay gold ponyboy
Stumbled upon this in the news today, which is so appropriate given the topic of our class discussion.

Google’s car is super cute. I almost wanted to give it a hug after I saw the picture in the Times. It belongs in a happy cartoon world where everyone obediently stays at the speed limit and stops at every stop sign and yields to every pedestrian and otherwise follows the law to a T, but unfortunately we don’t live in that kind of world. If you drive the speed limit on 280, you might be safe from the law, but what use is that if you’re fatally injured by the impatient, 75 mph driver behind you? 

One quote in the Times article that I thought was a little bit haunting: “One Google car, in a test in 2009, couldn’t get through a four-way stop because its sensors kept waiting for other (human) drivers to stop completely and let it go. The human drivers kept inching forward, looking for the advantage — paralyzing Google’s robot.” 

One more thing that’s not related to cars but still related to this idea. A movie called Ex Machina came out earlier this year that explored the boundaries of artificial intelligence. Without spoiling too much of the plot, what I gathered from it (not that I watched it. It was R-rated and I follow the law!!111!!) was that the only way robots are able to pass the Turing test and prove that they are human is to exhibit the most human trait of all – selfish manipulation. 

Are humans, like the Federalists suggest, naturally evil and selfish? Cars are a halfway decent analogy for the economy because some may argue that the economy regulates itself – likewise, everyone on the highway has to drive while considering how fast/slow everyone else is driving. Is the natural speed check that comes with the presence of other drivers enough, or is governmental intervention necessary? And if governmental intervention IS necessary, how can we make the most out of it, considering there are still people who don’t take the regulations seriously? 


What do you think? Feel free to give examples of situations other than cars, though you’re welcome to talk about that too.